I reported already earlier about the Lykoi cats. I did introduce the Lykoi cats and the breeders and I talked about the big chance that the Lykoi cats might become very popular. But as I mentioned in this article, I am not the only one who reported about the Lykoi kitties and I mentioned that they recently got a lot of media attention. They were features on Yahoo Shine to name just one example.
As I think it is an interesting subject, I didn´t only read most of the articles about the Lykoi cats, I also did read many comments on Yahoo Shine for example. But there is one thing I noticed,… even if the Lykoi cats are a natural occurring mutation, not all people do agree that this is a reason to make efforts to step in with the goal to establish them as a breed. This is what I take from many comments on the Yahoo Shine article. I must admit that some comments make me thoughtful and while I really like the Lykoi cats, I must say that some commentators make some good points. The question should be allowed. Is it ethically meaningful to selectively breed animals with a natural occurring mutation to make them purebred?
Some users say that even if the mutation natural occurred, you selectively need to find another cat with the same mutation to make them purebred and this is what the breeder have done. They found cats with the same mutation and were able to their breeding program. Some people argue that this is not a natural occurred breed then as there was still human intervention.
Then some argue that there already enough homeless cats and that breeding even more or creating even a new breed is therefore careless. Some people go so far and say that they think the breeders decided to profit from a chance mutation and that there can´t be any other logical reason to start this breeding program.
Some call this new cat breed “designer cats” and see nothing else than yet another business model to the disadvantage of the cats.
I must say that are some strong arguments and after reading a lot of comments, I guess that I did even leave some of the arguments of the people out here. On the other side I wrote about the efforts of the breeders in my other article. It really looks like they did make a lot of efforts to rule out that there aren´t any diseases or disorders that might have caused the unusual appearance of the cats. Visiting their website it seems that the breeders have a lot of experience and that they are excited about this new breed and that they do everything with care.
I must say I have a problem to forge my own opinion here. The detractors of this breeding program make some good points but I wouldn´t imply that the breeders do all this just because of the money. Breeding is their interest and I can imagine how excited it can be to discover a new breed which even appears to be healthy. I do understand the excitement and the plan to establish these kitties but as said, I do also understand the other side that says we have already enough homeless cats and that it isn´t meaningful to breed more of them or to establish even a new breed.
What do you think about this subject? Do you think it is ethically meaningful to find a breeding pair with the same mutation to establish this kind of breed? Could this really be considered as a natural occurring breed? Or do you think that the human intervention is unethical? Or do you have another opinion why this is ok or not ok? What do you think about the werewolf cats?